Good Practices

Mondragon Unibertsitatea – Campus Galarreta

The 3SqAir project is a multi-partner and cross-border project. Its main goal is to design a “Smart” and “Sustainable” action plan, to ensure, through a common quality approach, the indoor air quality of French, Spanish and Portuguese educational buildings.

  • The Deliverable 3.1.2-Best Practices guidelines and criteria indicators for better Indoor Air Quality in classrooms – was developed within the scope of the Activity 3.1of the project 3SqAir. The objective of this technical report is to define and present feedback on a remarkable indoor air quality (IAQ) management operation, through a reference framework of IAQ criteria in order to assess the inclusion of IAQ in school buildings.

    This reference framework was established as part of the task 3.1.2 of the 3SQAIR project, the deliverable of which can be downloaded from the project website www.3SqAir.com

    The approach has a dual objective:
    – Improve stakeholder knowledge on how to manage IAQ in their own buildings.
    – Propose a common methodology for comparative studies on “best practice” case studies.

  • The objective of the 3SQAIR project is to define RIS31 strategies to improve indoor air quality IAQ in classrooms. One of the levers to achieve this objective is to share best practices (BP) with all stakeholders in order to enhance their knowledge, and consequently, their practices. To this end, we propose to identify the major action criteria to help stakeholders to improve IAQ in educational buildings.

    Our work consisted in drawing up a first state of the art of methodologies for assessing the IAQ in educational buildings. This first analysis made it possible to identify a list of IAQ improvement levers considering technical and organizational. And, we propose a simplified methodology assessing a synthesis profile of the IAQ for feedback from operations.

    In fact, the characterization of IAQ has many components, themselves linked to the complexity of the life cycle of a building. Such an analysis must be holistic because the IAQ of a classroom also depends on organizational aspects (maintenance and management of real estate), sociological (behavior and comfort of the occupants), economic (available resources) and even political considerations (exemplary public policies for contractors).

    We propose a baseline to define common criteria for promoting best practices in IAQ in classrooms, which also lays down common guideline settings for smart, sustainable and energy efficient IAQ solutions. Through a selective bibliographic study and an in-depth presentation of the modeling of IAQ pollutants, we have identified 10 major indicators for the inclusion of IAQ, classified into 2 areas:

    1. Building Facilities: “Technical Solutions On Iaq And Ventilation”

    a) Pollutant sources
    b) Intake and exhausts
    c) Filtration
    d) Air renewal systems
    e) Air purification

    2. Stakeholders Organization: “Management”

    f) Cost
    g) Occupants’ comfort and behavior
    h) Communication and quality management systems
    i) Maintenance
    j) Sustainability (environmental impact & energy efficient strategies)

    This report offers a common reference simplified methodology to establish comparative studies on IAQ in educational buildings. This methodology constitutes a basis for the practical resource (best practices experience feedback case studies) for stakeholders that have to be produced within the 3SqAir project, through the eponymous online platform website. It will be used to build an analysis framework for the 12 operations that are the subject of experience feedback as part of task 3.2.1 of the 3SQAIR project.

  • This study has taken place in Orona Ideo, which is the ecosystem that gathers in one place all the agents involved in the innovation network – company (Orona), university (Mondragon Unibertsitatea) and research center (Ikerlan) – to promote a greater exchange of knowledge and ideas that will ultimately be transformed into results.
    The collaboration between the three entities forms a technology alliance applied to the mobility sector and the improvement and transformation of companies and society.
    This space is much more than a set of facilities, it is the place where an idea or a project needs to grow and consolidate. It is composed by:

    • Orona Zero: the corporate headquarters of Orona, a leading European business group in sustainable vertical mobility of people.
    • Orona Fundazioa: the building that houses the classrooms where Mondragon Unibertsitatea teaches its two degrees in Energy Engineering and Engineering in Green Manufacturing.
    • A3 Research: It is an advanced building designed for the development of the integrated projects of the innovation network related to energy, managed by Ikerlan.Your

    More information in www.orona-ideo.com.
    The room where the study has taken place is:
    MONDRAGON UNIBERTSITATEA
    Room F1 04
    MONDRAGON UNIBERTSITATEA – MONDRAGON UNIVERSITY
    (43.276030, – 1.985543)
    (https://vr.mondragon.edu/bisitabirtuala/oronaideo/)

    Figure 1. Aerial view of Orona-IDEO Innovation City.
    Location of the room at the first floor in Orona Fundazioa building
  • A) Pollutant sources:

    The Outdoor Environmental Zone

    Urban area
    Rural area
    Industrial area nearby
    Nearest gas station (less than 1km)
    Commercial zone
    Parking lot
    Presence of electromagnetic waves

    The Indoor Environmental Zone

    Heating method
    Wall and floor coverings

    Luminaire type: fluorescent

    B) Intake and exhausts:

    The intake and exhausts don’t self-adjust. The mechanical ventilations humidity-controlled air inlets are Centralized 2 DOAS (Dedicated Outside Air Systems) systems for the whole building ventilation. In the room there are 2 fan coils with 4 intake ports per each fan coil (thermostat control).

    The outlets are controlled by Centralized 2 DOAS (Dedicated Outside Air Systems) systems for whole building ventilation. At the room there are 2 outlets to return air. The natural ventilation has a 23.6 m2 of windows, West oriented.

    C) Filtration:

    D) Air renewal systems:

    There are two Dedicated Outside Air Systems for conditioning the primary air of the Orona Fundazioa building where is sited the demo site. The DOAS have 2 fans for air inlet and exhaust respectively, rotatory heat recovery heat exchanger of 62% efficiency, heating and cooling coils, free cooling performance and F6+F8 air filters.

    E) Air purification:

    On this demo-site there are F6+F8 filters in the DOAS.

  • The maintenance team is composed by 1 internal person that is part of the contracting authority and the maintenance services provide by external companies. The type of system is a centralized digital platform where the set points and real data are recorded.

    F) Cost

    G) Occupants’ comfort and behavior

    H) Communication and quality management systems

    Certification 1 – The building was designed to be passive buildings and they obtained LEED Gold and BREEAM  Excellent certifications.

    I) Maintenance

    J) Sustainability (environmental impact and energy efficiency strategies)

    Sustainability refers to the ability to maintain or support a process continuously over time. Sustainability seeks to prevent the depletion of natural or physical resources, so that they remain available over time.

  • This work proposes a methodology for evaluating the IAQ in educational buildings. Through a deliberately simplified approach, we have defined a baseline based on two domains describing the building’s facilities and the organization of the whole stakeholder chain actors.

    A summary of the multi-criteria analysis for this operation is presented in the form of a radar made up of the 10 benchmark indicators, established in task 3.1.2 of the 3SqAir project.

    We have previously indicated that this type of analysis requires a transversal (holistic) approach, since all these criteria are interconnected and influence each other. In order to determine the relevance of taking into account the IAQ of a building, we propose to carry out a two-step approach:

    1)First, an analytical approach: characterization of each of the 10 criteria separately, through a qualitative or quantitative approach;

    2)Secondly, a global synthesis, through a graphic representation in the form of a “3SqAir profile”, with a radar representation, according to the a “basic” or “thorough” rating scale (see below, an example of fictive radars on the basis of a 1-5 scale, with a representation mode).

     

    For operation Mondragon Unibertsitatea-Ikerlan, the result is as follows:

    This result was established after a collective analysis of all operations, during the workshop held in Coimbra (Portugal) on 08/11/2022. During this workshop, the partners presented the 12 feedbacks and voted collectively to define the level of performance for each criterion and establish the corresponding radar profile.